It could also be used for diegetic, rather than meta-narrative system.
For example, there could be a square grid with alchemical ingredients that player can fill with effects, and then use any of the effects as long as they _don't_ create a straight line. Straight line produces a super-powered potion, but fully spends all ingredients until the next resupply.
I put a Library Bingo card in Song of the Scryptwyrm that consists of ticking off various activities if you do them. It's presented as an in-world item, but is designed such that you could mark off a combination of things your character does (e.g., travel backwards in time) and things you - the player - have done (e.g., read to someone). There's a game-related bonus available if you mark off a full line, provided you've deciphered the coded message that explains that bit...
The focus above seems to be on marking your bingo card when something narrative (or meta) happens. We could change the emphasis slightly: when you mark your card — because the number on your square matches the ball drawn (which, yes, is a “meta” event, but it is an “empty” one) — some narrative element written on that square is added: “88: You notice someone is following you.”
Give everyone different numbers on their cards — no overlap — and this is a way of distributing the spotlight. (Or have some overlap but different narrative elements for each character who matches, possibly suggesting seemingly incompatible turns in the story.)
Each line can have its extra narrative element when completed: something promising for a horizontal line; something ominous for a vertical line. Line “bonuses” can sometimes be meta: “Scratch out one square which hasn’t matched yet: its element won’t be triggered.” Completing a line on your card could cause a square to match/element to trigger on another player’s card.
A method of randomly injecting narrative challenges for the players — and GM, if there is one — but like a depth crawl, it can have a degree of memory.
My Body Is A Cage by snow was my first but I don't think last time seeing TTRPG bingo. It has some of them on the itch preview page so everyone should go check it out. Basically milestone-based advancement but on a bingo card, with benefits as you make different lines and rows.
The game has a great grab bag of ideas, like a crossword puzzle to get random equipment (also visible on the preview page). And that's aside from being, structurally, a Persona RPG.
Interesting idea. I may create an “experience bingo card” for my solo 2D6 sci-fi game with a 4x3 grid, numbered 1-12. “1” will be filled in for free. When a character has filled in all the boxes 2-12 by rolling skill checks they can gain a skill level. Maybe they need to fill in each box twice, I’m not sure how long it will take. But it means rolling a 2 has some benefit
* Bingo card == HP; 5x4 maybe (or 5x5 with a row of "free spaces")
* Allow players to distribute the numbers 1-20 as they like (and assign free spaces if used)
* When player's character takes damage, the DM rolls a d20 (or multiple if the damage is severe enough) and each number would then correspond to a square on the card.
* A completed row, column, or diagonal could trigger to injury or status condition
* Healing could clear some of the squares
* Duplicates rolled by the DM could be "free" (lucky you) or maybe you'd be forced to fill in an adjacent square
* Maybe free spaces are also special. They could represent something like "catching your breath" and are easily cleared after a fight. Maybe a player could opt to fill one of these instead of a DM rolled number?
Got me thinking about abilities or skills tied to a grid. 3x3, 4x2, 5x5. Different abilities activated when getting the corners, vertical or horizontal or diagona linesl. Let encounters be tied to bingo cards as well. Activate one pip early 'at a cost' but now you can't reuse that skipped square for a different ability.
Then just...draw numbers.
Maybe as players get more powerful they have more cards...but then they have to manage as the called numbers go faster than they can tick the boxes.
I dunno...got me thinking that there's definitely something worth mining there.
Not quite what you’re talking about, but you should look at how bingo cards are used in the competitive speedrunning scene for certain video games like Blue Prince or Mario Odyssey
This inspired some thoughts! I love the idea of using Bingo Cards to level up; some of my players like attaching story progression to their level ups, gives them a reason that they learned new skills.
I also like the idea of using Bingo as a Battle Mechanic / Puzzle, a 5x5 rooms grid and solvable puzzles or encounters. If they complete a line, the big boss shows up or something. The party arrives at the battle separated across the map. Then they can realize it’s a big Bingo Board with clues in the rooms.
Helping players get into their characters using Bingo cards too is great, helps with character motivation. This could also help when a player is requesting something like an extra feat or certain skill. So many ways to use this!
Definitely taking this thought and applying it somehow to my games.
as soon as i read, "The proof of this paradox gets very mathy indeed", i knew i had to read the paper :D i'm very glad that i did, because combinatorics is one of my favourite areas of math (at least in terms of puzzly fun) ^^ that was awesome!
all in all, this was such an exciting read :) really sparking so many ideas ^^ i was planning to, in the next DnD thing i run for my weekly friend group ttrpg, incorporate some kind of "advancement/experience questions" with narrative flair, to make it more fun for me and to incorporate some "incentives" for cool stuff to happen, but now having read this article + the linked articles by Judd, i'm definitely going to propose to the group to do something like Bingo Lvl up/xp ^^
super cool to read all the other comments too :) really appreciated! thank you for sparking this conversation <3
It could also be used for diegetic, rather than meta-narrative system.
For example, there could be a square grid with alchemical ingredients that player can fill with effects, and then use any of the effects as long as they _don't_ create a straight line. Straight line produces a super-powered potion, but fully spends all ingredients until the next resupply.
That's a fun idea. Thanks!
I put a Library Bingo card in Song of the Scryptwyrm that consists of ticking off various activities if you do them. It's presented as an in-world item, but is designed such that you could mark off a combination of things your character does (e.g., travel backwards in time) and things you - the player - have done (e.g., read to someone). There's a game-related bonus available if you mark off a full line, provided you've deciphered the coded message that explains that bit...
Nice!
Curious, do you count diagonals as BINGO as well?
That I do!
Some random thoughts of a thoughtless fellow…
The focus above seems to be on marking your bingo card when something narrative (or meta) happens. We could change the emphasis slightly: when you mark your card — because the number on your square matches the ball drawn (which, yes, is a “meta” event, but it is an “empty” one) — some narrative element written on that square is added: “88: You notice someone is following you.”
Give everyone different numbers on their cards — no overlap — and this is a way of distributing the spotlight. (Or have some overlap but different narrative elements for each character who matches, possibly suggesting seemingly incompatible turns in the story.)
Each line can have its extra narrative element when completed: something promising for a horizontal line; something ominous for a vertical line. Line “bonuses” can sometimes be meta: “Scratch out one square which hasn’t matched yet: its element won’t be triggered.” Completing a line on your card could cause a square to match/element to trigger on another player’s card.
A method of randomly injecting narrative challenges for the players — and GM, if there is one — but like a depth crawl, it can have a degree of memory.
As always, you provide some interesting ideas!
Thanks for your comment!
My Body Is A Cage by snow was my first but I don't think last time seeing TTRPG bingo. It has some of them on the itch preview page so everyone should go check it out. Basically milestone-based advancement but on a bingo card, with benefits as you make different lines and rows.
The game has a great grab bag of ideas, like a crossword puzzle to get random equipment (also visible on the preview page). And that's aside from being, structurally, a Persona RPG.
Not sure how I missed this one. Many have pointed it out since I've posted this. I'll definitely check it out. Thanks!!
Interesting idea. I may create an “experience bingo card” for my solo 2D6 sci-fi game with a 4x3 grid, numbered 1-12. “1” will be filled in for free. When a character has filled in all the boxes 2-12 by rolling skill checks they can gain a skill level. Maybe they need to fill in each box twice, I’m not sure how long it will take. But it means rolling a 2 has some benefit
Sounds interesting!
Interesting article. I agree there is potential for bingo mechanics in a ttrpg.
Thanks!
You're welcome.
This article planted the seed of an idea:
* Bingo card == HP; 5x4 maybe (or 5x5 with a row of "free spaces")
* Allow players to distribute the numbers 1-20 as they like (and assign free spaces if used)
* When player's character takes damage, the DM rolls a d20 (or multiple if the damage is severe enough) and each number would then correspond to a square on the card.
* A completed row, column, or diagonal could trigger to injury or status condition
* Healing could clear some of the squares
* Duplicates rolled by the DM could be "free" (lucky you) or maybe you'd be forced to fill in an adjacent square
* Maybe free spaces are also special. They could represent something like "catching your breath" and are easily cleared after a fight. Maybe a player could opt to fill one of these instead of a DM rolled number?
Got me thinking about abilities or skills tied to a grid. 3x3, 4x2, 5x5. Different abilities activated when getting the corners, vertical or horizontal or diagona linesl. Let encounters be tied to bingo cards as well. Activate one pip early 'at a cost' but now you can't reuse that skipped square for a different ability.
Then just...draw numbers.
Maybe as players get more powerful they have more cards...but then they have to manage as the called numbers go faster than they can tick the boxes.
I dunno...got me thinking that there's definitely something worth mining there.
“Got me thinking” the best complement to receive after writing an SCM article!! Thank you! ☺️
Not quite what you’re talking about, but you should look at how bingo cards are used in the competitive speedrunning scene for certain video games like Blue Prince or Mario Odyssey
Will do! Thanks!
This inspired some thoughts! I love the idea of using Bingo Cards to level up; some of my players like attaching story progression to their level ups, gives them a reason that they learned new skills.
I also like the idea of using Bingo as a Battle Mechanic / Puzzle, a 5x5 rooms grid and solvable puzzles or encounters. If they complete a line, the big boss shows up or something. The party arrives at the battle separated across the map. Then they can realize it’s a big Bingo Board with clues in the rooms.
Helping players get into their characters using Bingo cards too is great, helps with character motivation. This could also help when a player is requesting something like an extra feat or certain skill. So many ways to use this!
Definitely taking this thought and applying it somehow to my games.
as soon as i read, "The proof of this paradox gets very mathy indeed", i knew i had to read the paper :D i'm very glad that i did, because combinatorics is one of my favourite areas of math (at least in terms of puzzly fun) ^^ that was awesome!
all in all, this was such an exciting read :) really sparking so many ideas ^^ i was planning to, in the next DnD thing i run for my weekly friend group ttrpg, incorporate some kind of "advancement/experience questions" with narrative flair, to make it more fun for me and to incorporate some "incentives" for cool stuff to happen, but now having read this article + the linked articles by Judd, i'm definitely going to propose to the group to do something like Bingo Lvl up/xp ^^
super cool to read all the other comments too :) really appreciated! thank you for sparking this conversation <3
I must admit I thought of you when I wrote that! Thought that might send you down the rabbit hole of reading papers! :)